Does anybody know of a good website that gives the pros and cons of playing different band instruments?

I’m a school band teacher and am looking for a good website to refer parents to when deciding what instrument their child should play. If there’s not one out there, I’ll create one myself, but if there is … why reinvent the wheel?

What a great question! I’ve been answering the same questions over and over for years and have yet to find a great objective resource for this. Your question led me to surf a little, which I assume you’ve probably done, as well. I liked

http://webs.davis.k12.ut.us/rsiegel/AboutInstIndex.html

as a source of instrument information, including audio examples.

I found an interesting list of "ideal attributes" for each instrument on a cached page at

http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:RxHquKLYE6cJ:www.mccsc.edu/~raustin/chooseobtain.htm+choosing+a+band+instrument&cd=3&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a

but I would caution parents not to put too much weight on these unless there is an extreme physical problem. I strongly believe that if a student has a strong desire to play a particular instrument, almost any "physical mismatch" can be overcome. On the other hand, if they don’t show a strong preference, looking at which might provide the best chance for "natural" success makes sense.

I’d be interested in knowing what you decide to recommend or create.

One Response to “Does anybody know of a good website that gives the pros and cons of playing different band instruments?”

  1. What a great question! I’ve been answering the same questions over and over for years and have yet to find a great objective resource for this. Your question led me to surf a little, which I assume you’ve probably done, as well. I liked

    http://webs.davis.k12.ut.us/rsiegel/AboutInstIndex.html

    as a source of instrument information, including audio examples.

    I found an interesting list of "ideal attributes" for each instrument on a cached page at

    http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:RxHquKLYE6cJ:www.mccsc.edu/~raustin/chooseobtain.htm+choosing+a+band+instrument&cd=3&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=firefox-a

    but I would caution parents not to put too much weight on these unless there is an extreme physical problem. I strongly believe that if a student has a strong desire to play a particular instrument, almost any "physical mismatch" can be overcome. On the other hand, if they don’t show a strong preference, looking at which might provide the best chance for "natural" success makes sense.

    I’d be interested in knowing what you decide to recommend or create.
    References :
    Decades as a band director and a little web surfing.

Leave a Reply